Monday, April 16, 2012

Are women our own Worst Enemies?

Posted in: , , ,
This is an often repeated question, and one that has come up in some of my conversations and some I've seen around the web recently. Why are we women the worst critics of each other? And I'm not talking constructive criticism here, but nit-picking of the most bilious kind.


Omotola Jalade, a well known actress who has been working in the entertainment industry for over 10 years, still has her age and looks questioned, and yesterday got into a heated Twitter exchange. No one can deny that such unwarranted stabs can be very irritating. Thing is, most of these comments are from women. Especially online where they can be anonymous, women go around spreading poison to other women, even ones they don't know.

Some have blamed these sorts of woman-to-woman attacks on how the society we live in has conditioned women's behavior by denying them of real power over time. This powerlessness results in low self esteem, and the belief that men are out of bounds but not other women as rivals. Some psychologists point to evolution and insist these subtle or overt hostility between women is genetic and stems from competition for men, and for resources for our children.

No matter the genesis of these traits in us, I am of the opinion that at this stage, we women should be more self aware when dealing with other women. Let's regard each other less as rivals than as partners in a society that is still not the most conducive for us. We were limited in days gone to our looks or being able to get married or have children but times have changed a bit since then.

Now, we can get educated and we can have careers, in addition to having marriages and children if we want. In the work place as well in the public sphere, we can actually help each other excel. Let us focus less on how good or bad we look, or how a more beautiful woman will get more attention, or how we can put an  ugly one in her place. Let us think on ways we can support each other.

Ashley Judd in promoting her show, Missing, was harassed by the media for looking "puffy". She replied on the Daily Beast, decrying the culture where women join in to tear down other women. She writes;

The Conversation about women happens everywhere, publicly and privately. We are described and detailed, our faces and bodies analyzed and picked apart, our worth ascertained and ascribed based on the reduction of personhood to simple physical objectification. Our voices, our personhood, our potential, and our accomplishments are regularly minimized and muted.
...

That women are joining in the ongoing disassembling of my appearance is salient. Patriarchy is not men. Patriarchy is a system in which both women and men participate. It privileges, inter alia, the interests of boys and men over the bodily integrity, autonomy, and dignity of girls and women. It is subtle, insidious, and never more dangerous than when women passionately deny that they themselves are engaging in it. ... A case in point is that this conversation was initially promulgated largely by women; a sad and disturbing fact.
....

I hope the sharing of my thoughts can generate a new conversation: Why was a puffy face cause for such a conversation in the first place? How, and why, did people participate? If not in the conversation about me, in parallel ones about women in your sphere? What is the gloating about? What is the condemnation about?
...

How can we as individuals in our private lives make adjustments that support us in shedding unconscious actions, internalized beliefs, and fears about our worthiness, that perpetuate such meanness? What can we do as families, as groups of friends? Is what girls and women can do different from what boys and men can do? What does this have to do with how women are treated in the workplace?

I ask especially how we can leverage strong female-to-female alliances to confront and change that there is no winning here as women.
...
Some high profile women have taken up that call immediately, and very publicly too. We indeed can be models, mentors and partners instead of enemies. Beyonce recently posted an open letter on her website addressed to American First Lady, where she praised Mrs. Obama as “the ULTIMATE example of a truly strong African American woman.” She added, “I am proud to have my daughter grow up in a world where she has people like you to look up to.” Michelle Obama soon tweeted back. "@Beyonce Thank you for the beautiful letter and for being a role model who kids everwhere can look up to. -mo" As you can imagine, I was absolutely thrilled by this exchange. I admire Beyonce a lot and Michelle Obama inspires me.

This post is my own way of continuing the conversation. I have also tasted that Hollywood coolaid of remarking on people's looks, especially women. But it's never too late to have a re-think. We need to learn to compliment and support ourselves. This is the only way we can become better people and make the world better for women. Like Ghandi said, we should be the change we wish to see.




37 comments:

  1. Myne, to be honest I sighed when I saw the title of your post. A part of me thought, Oh no, not this again.

    I am one of the people who strongly believes women are NOT their own worst enemies. Women are simply more expressive, more emotional, we say things and feel things and sometimes we may hurt each other in the process. Look, a man may see a picture of a woman and think, to himself, "that woman is very unattractive", but a woman will actually more times than often actually say it out loud to her friend beside her. Both people felt the same response and had the same opinion, but one kept it to self and the other "unleashed it" (for lack of a better word) to the public.

    Some of my best friends in this world are women, and I love them dearly. They have taught me, inspired me and been there for me. No they are not perfect but we accept each other in spite of our short comings. I think this myth of women hating each other is untrue and needs to be checked. Frankly, Guys have shown me pepper o, gossiped about me, said stuff that wasn't true, etc. But I notice when men do it, we seem to chalk it down to just them being stupid or silly at the moment.

    I wrote a post about this a while ago on my blog where I expressed my opinion about the women who seem to love to hate women and perpetuate this idea of unending enimity amongst females:

    http://mimibarber.blogspot.co.uk/2011/07/ode-to-friendship.html

    Sorry for the epistle but i feel VERY strongly about this matter.

    I think women are amazing creatures and I thank God every day for bringing me into this life as one. Lol. : )

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mimi, I am also of the opinion that women are not our own WORST enemies, but we are frequently enemies of each other, especially of those who do not know and who are not our friends. Why does a woman need to call out that another is unattractive? You say a man sees it and looks away, why can't we try to be the same? In fact, can't we even look for a good thing about that same person to compliment?

      Delete
  2. More often than not, when you have an opinion post like this I'm usually on the other side of the argument but this time I agree with you.

    The little things really are the things that get me just like the comment above mine was saying that if women see an unattractive woman they turn to their friends and tell them that the lady is unattractive.

    More often than not you've seen a group of two or three women sitting together and commenting on every female that walks in "O why is she wearing that?" "What happened to her hair?" ...and after a good looking lady walks in they all go quiet.

    Why is it so hard for females to say a nice thing to another female without wanting anything in return? I've always wondered...

    ...Most women have a stunned look on their face when I tell them that "I love your dress" or "you look good". My own is simply if I like it I tell you, if I don't then I keep it to myself (why speak if you have nothing nice to say) but if someone beside me notices the negative and decides to talk to me about it, I won't turn a deaf ear sha

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi NRe, I'm glad we can agree and disagree sometimes and still be civil. Thanks for reading and your considered response.

      Delete
  3. Please don't get yourself involved in such rants in future because you have your own image to protect. Also, her hubby once said that she is a ? No bi for my mouth dem go hear say teacher's mama na witch. http://www.nairaland.com/13258/omotola-husband-sayz-witch

    Seriously, Omosexy went too far and that is how she really is. She had hidden her true character for a very long time, that was why a lot of people were shocked. The tweet actually meant that she looked good for her age but lack of education and exposure did not allow her to see it that way.

    She has not done anything spectacular in her life but pride comes before a fall. A celebrity should NEVER argue with fans or abuse them via tweets because it is unprofessional. Some people (worldwide) are ill mannered anyway.

    Mary J Blige has a lot of respect for her fans. At times I wonder why.
    Nobody can beat Mary J Blige in that regard. She even 'protects' her fans during interviews. She probably knows that without those fans, she would be nobody. Even when her songs were no longer in vogue, she remained famous, even till now. Wow!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry I don't think you read the article well or you get the whole point of the article. She was just using that incident to stress a point.

      Delete
    2. Hi Anonymous, did you read the whole article? You are doing exactly what I'm calling for us as women to be careful about.

      Delete
    3. Hi anon,I cant believe you,that tweet was no compliment,before you argue,go on twitter,check Omotola's page and checkthat Uche dude's TL you'd be in a better place to judge. about her doing anythiing spectacular in her life,is it until she she dies for you before you see it so! FYI she hasn't fallen.

      Delete
  4. woman are one part of a mans life,they are wonderful nd greatfully made by God::::.they deserve more nd more respect 4rm d men...

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't know why it is but it is true that as women, we are very critical of each other. Omotola may have been reacting to a series of comments about her age and just happened to respond to this particular person.

    I think some women only fell better about themselves when they are putting others down and that's a pity. I'm a strong believer in complimenting other women and sometimes pointing out to them, privately I hasten to add, if there is something wrong with their appearance so they can right it. For example, if they have snot in their nose or something in their eye or hair etc. It is what I hope others would do for me should I be in a similar position.

    We have much to learn and give to and from each other. Let's stop with the bitching and be more supportive of each other.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sorry that should be 'some women only feel better...'

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Wordsmythe. The question then is, could we be less critical, especially when we have nothing good to say, or no value to add like in your examples. I hope we can do so, one woman at a time.

      Delete
  7. @Myne

    The truth is that some women suffer from low self-esteem and will talk trash to look down on another woman. I think Omotola is sexy and whether she is 34 or 43 yrs, still looks great for her age and have accomplished a lot for herself and family.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh well. this matter about women again. I totally agree with you but the bitter truth is that like wordsmythe said, putting other women down makes some women feel better about themselves. We are forever judging one another. Our clothes, our appearance, our body, marriage, choice of partner..everything. It does make me wonder sometimes. There is a wall between constructive criticism and saying loads of nonsense just to bring a fellow woman down. We need to appreciate one another more and whoever said women are their own worst enemies only saw how some women are eager to run other women down. We all are beautiful in our own way. We need to totally understand this. Nice article Myne.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Lily. I wish more of us will realize this.

      Delete
  9. I think the criticisms come from both males and females. Men are known for very hurtful comments, but as was said above, women are more vocal in their opinions. And women criticise both males and females so....

    But it hurts more when Ųя fellow woman criticises and puts you down. Also females are more sensitive, and feel they're constantly being weighed and measured, like in a competition. A male would normally shrug off criticisms about himself, and take it in stride. A female would ponder and ruminate over it, and almost get depressed!

    DrLily

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You've hit the nail on the head. Thanks, DrLily

      Delete
  10. Hmmm..read the article and analyzed the psychologists view, and all i can say is......abeggy, all nah bad belly o jare!....when that green-eye demon called jealousy possess some women...that is the type of result you would see, that just happened in twitters.

    She looks good, regardless her age and many women WISH to be like her but CANNOT be like her...so, they find any excuse to run her down, to make themselves feel better...ha! the heart of a man is wicked!

    There are two things that can cause jealousy btw women; MAN OR MONEY!

    larwdy, have mercy! when a woman possess both! the bad bellies go plenty!

    And to your question...it is a CAPITAL YES!..we are own worst enemy! The book of Genesis about Hagar and Sarah is a proof.

    Do i need to say more?....i rest my case and carry my apoti waka comot jeje, before i write post for inside this post...good nite oo, Myne.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Simply Mee, I sometimes wonder, why the need for this jealousy, envy or competition?

      Delete
  11. I thing we all just need to stop hating & start appreciating more

    Lol@Simply Me

    ReplyDelete
  12. Nothing I can add to the discussion. All there needs to be said has been said.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I kinda agree with the first poster because I have been known to say that a particular dress does not look very good on a person. I personally don't think that is a problem expressing an opinion. The question really is where is that opinion coming from? Is there any truth to that opinion? Is there hate or most importantly jealousy involved...then that is when it gets problematic?

    I have had people come to me and talk to me about the fact that I carry my hair in its natural state. Some expressed their opinion nicely and some not so nicely. You listen and then separate. Ask yourself where that person is coming from, is there any truth to it and you take it or drop it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep... i agree the motive behind the thought is critical..

      Delete
    2. Lovely insight, Pamela. I don't mind criticism myself when the intentions are positive like you said.

      Delete
  14. Women tend to come together when they want to fight for their rights etc., otherwise they are not usually nice to one another.

    @1st Anonymous, I think you meant Mariah Carey instead of Mary J Blige.

    On Jolade's response tweet, the comment was from a man. The guy does not look like a failure to me. He probably knows a younger famous Nollywood actress according to his pictures on twitter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ahhh...is that what was going on? I see.

      Delete
  15. I think it's low self esteem!!! and maybe that competition for "men"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Low self-esteem is definitely part of it. Guess more of us need to work on that.

      Delete
  16. Nice one. I sincerely agree with you. As a young mother and a maternal Newborn and Child health advocate,I have been privileged to visit the field in my quest to find out why women die during pregnancy and child birth and one of the issues is directed to the fact that women (themselves) that give birth naturally are seen as "stronger" women and if a woman cannot push the baby naturally and must go through a caesarean section is seen as a "weaker" woman.So many women have died wanting to be "strong", risk their lives trying to please their mothers, mother-in-laws and other women around.And in situations when women loose their husbands, they are treated unjustly by their fellow women.
    I strongly feel we(women) should be best friends and when we are, the world will be a better place

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is really sad to hear. I hope this rivalry will get better with time and better education and opportunities for women

      Delete
  17. Clearly, this is a strong issue brewing amongst some women.

    I will add that "people not just women and men will say things whether good or evil".

    Can I just say, "I dont see beyonce as a role model does that mean am badmouthing her". Nope, it is the way I said it, if I attacked her and her personal life then its different.

    oh well...

    Nollywood should berra make move on this.. call it WOMEN BASHING WOMEN WHY?, LOL..

    good points..

    I do think its boils down to what in our hearts.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I have a blog post 3/4 written with this same title lol. I tend to think women can be their worst enemies too. most of the institutions that entrench these societal rules for the genders are run by women. Men dont go to meetings to discuss how to keep their women subservient and suffering or tear other men down, but women on the other hand sit in meetings, living rooms, blackberries and destroy fellow women's reputations. Sometimes i think its cause we don't know our potential.

    ReplyDelete
  19. May I refer you all to 'How to be a woman' by the feminist thinker and journalist Caitlin Moran. That woman speaks my language. Among the many things that we agree on is that THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS 'THE SISTERHOOD'. I think women are too quick to ascribe everything that happens to them as an attack on sisterhood. What is this bloody sisterhood that we speak of? We don't have the same looks, cultures, understanding. We all have vaginas but men all have penises too.

    My point? Men bash at each other and women and yet there are no other men bleating on about 'role models' and 'The brotherhood'. Let us not deceive ourselves. While we are busy theorizing about female attacks on other females, what are the men doing? Getting on with the business of controlling the whole world.

    People attack people, they smear people, they bash people and you just have to surround yourself with positivity, love from those who care about you, put your head down and just get on with the business of living.

    Once you get it into your head that there is ABSOLUTELY NO REASON why women of the world should unite, then you'll be able to progress.

    Next time, before one reacts, I'd invite you to ask the question: 'Would men bother with this?' and more often than not, your response will be 'Next!'

    ReplyDelete
  20. Myne ooooo!!! all this quarel on top '34??" If e come be 40 nko??
    She should just have chosen to read that tweet innocently, ie positively; taking it as a compliment. If you go check, them two don quarel before. This is not normal.
    And oh, hey, you dont have to respond to everything, granted, our bodies itch to respond all the time, but let go...let go...just let go oh. sometimes your silence is even more annoying.

    And on issue of women; I totally agree, we dont like ourrselves. When I go to a bank or anywhere I make a beeline for the men...they are much nicer to you. Gbam.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Women we are the worst enemies of ourselves, the rate at which we bash, criticize and bring down ourselves all in the name of commenting on a post is disheartening. I dont read people's comments on linda ikeji's blog, becos of the hurtful and mean words people use especially women, most especially when the post is on a woman God help us if the woman is a celebrity, most time I think is sheer envy and low self esteem that makes a woman bring down another. In reference to Toolz post on bellanaija " A Woman's Worth" You need to see some of the comments there, for God sake can't a woman air her view without getting bashed in return. In offices, schools, even in church you see woman hating on each other all becos of what??. I rest my case!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Pretty section of content. I simply stumbled upon your weblog
    and in accession capital to claim that I get actually enjoyed account your blog posts.
    Any way I'll be subscribing for your augment and even I success you get right of entry to constantly fast.

    My blog post how to pick up girls

    ReplyDelete

Click Post a Comment to share your thoughts, I'll love to hear from you. Thanks!

*Comments on old posts are moderated and may take sometime to be shown. That's just because I want to see them and respond to you if necessary.